This Week’s Worst Person In The World Of Sports: Brian Cashman
If you’re a sports fan and you don’t know who this is, you should probably go watch Bravo instead of ESPN. As a quick refresher, he is probably the most powerful and well-funded general manager in all of sports, especially since the death of former Yankees owner George Steinbrenner. Still don’t know who he is? Ok, for those of you in “special” classes: Brian Cashman is the longtime general manager of the New York Yankees.
First of all, the Yankees are not good, being outperformed by teams such as the Astros with less than half their total payroll (but twice the talent). This past offseason, in an attempt at regaining their early decade relevancy, the Yankees spent big, acquiring closer Aroldis Chapman and Starlin Castro, and banking on the healthy return of star players such as Alex Rodriguez, Mark Teixiera, Carlos Beltran and CC Sabathia to ignite a run towards World Series ring number twenty-eight in New York.
Like a broken condom, though, sometimes shit just doesn’t go as planned. From essentially day one, the Yankees have vacillated between mediocre and near Braves-level patheticism, never seriously challenging for what has become a stacked AL East trio headlined by the Blue Jays, Orioles, and Red Sox, all of which will likely make the playoffs. Languishing at the bottom with that team from Tampa I can’t believe hasn’t pulled a St. Louis Rams yet, the once mighty Yankees entered the week of the trade deadline in an almost totally unfamiliar position: seller.
Now to be fair, tanking does not bother me, especially in the MLB. I understand why teams sell off players to stock their farm systems, relieving the immense financial burden of waning stars for the promise and financial security of pre-arbitration contracts amidst salivating scouting departments. What I do not understand, however, is forcing players to retire, and unloading free agent signings not even a calendar year old. Chapman, for instance, signed with the Yankees just this year, appearing in less than 30 total games before being shipped off to Chicago. Fortunately for Aroldis, he landed in a good city with a great team, perhaps a palatable situation for him and his family. But who knows? Imagine if he was a fucking Cleveland Indian, or had to move to Canada? While I understand what Cashman is doing is squarely within the rules of the collective bargaining agreement, if you’re a free agent, can you trust the Yankees’ brass, who undoubtedly sold you on the incredible lifestyle of a young multi-millionaire in NYC and the chase for ring twenty-eight, after seeing their once prized acquisition dumped after half a year of nearly flawless on-field performance?
The worst, though, is what has happened to A-Rod (and maybe Teixiera, but less is known about that situation). For as polarizing as he is, Alex Rodriguez was a phenomenal baseball player, a focal point of an era that was rife with performance enhancement, with a few players (Bonds, A-Rod namely) somewhat inexplicably shouldering the brunt of the public’s disdain. Regardless of what he did in the past, the Yankees chose to resign Rodriguez, tried every way imaginable not to honor the rest of his contract though he lost almost $30 million in sales last season, and have now paraded him through the most humiliating supposed “victory lap” imaginable.
Rodriguez was unfairly benched for days at a time, completely unsupported by his manager and front office, supplanted in favor of far less able players, and forced to end a magnificent career on everyone’s terms but his own. The Yankees are on the hook for his money next season, the last of his record-setting contract, which I suppose adds some semblance of fairness to this mess, but leaving a man four home runs short of 700, refusing to play him even in the midst of a hopeless season, is senseless cruelty, and should provide a warning to all “stars” interested in donning the pinstripes in the future.
I understand this is a business, and I realize what Cashman is doing with an eye towards a 2017 free agency haul perhaps unrivaled in recent baseball history. But if you’re Harper, Stanton, and any of the other huge names that could find themselves on the market (Stanton has an option), maybe think twice about who you want to play for, and who you can trust.
The Yankees, my hometown team — this one hurts..
Image via YouTube
I’ll admit what cashmen has done the past 2-3 years I haven’t liked but I think he’s correcting his mistakes now. Trading away big stars and old guys like chapman, miller and beltran I think is a start. Adding to that the retirement of arod and texeria their heading in the right direction Look at the game just the other day the guys they had just called up tyler austin and aaron judge hit back to back home runs. Couple that with solid pitching from guys like Tanaka and betances I think they could definitely be a real threat next year.
8 years ago at 2:48 pmChapman is an old guy?
8 years ago at 2:49 pmGood article but tough to feel bad for A-Rod. He’ll finish out his career doing nothing but cashing checks. “But Story, what about his love for the game and team?”…that all went out the window when he cheated and used steroids. He did all that for fame and ultimately, more money. Yankees front office is doing the exact same thing, a financial decision that benefits them.
8 years ago at 2:48 pmJeter had an on base percentage of .250 his last year, Teixiera is hitting below .198 this year but you decide to bench the man 4 jacks away from 700? NF
8 years ago at 2:48 pmJeter means infinitely more to the Yankees organization than ARod does. Not even a comparison.
8 years ago at 2:53 pmRidiculous to compare Jeter to A Rod in terms of how their send offs were handled. Jeter is one of the most beloved figures in recent baseball history, and his OBP was over .300 even though he was old and broken down
8 years ago at 9:05 pmHard to feel bad for a guy that’s still getting paid another $27 million and finishes his career with the highest earnings in mlb history
8 years ago at 3:01 pmAbsolutely awful article. The Yankees playing at the braves level and sitting next to Tampa at the bottom of the AL East, aka 4.5 games out of the wild card?
Arod being sat for less-abled players? Seriously? The guy’s OPS is just above Aaron Hicks yet his WAR is worse. And he can’t even play the field. He is literally designated for hitting yet he can’t do that.
Between all their trades, they ended up getting Castro for Brendan Ryan, which is basically free. And traded away Chapman for some farm studs. No GM could have drawn up a better trade deadline. Oh yea, both Beltran and Chapman have expressed interest in returning. Actually, Chapman said he’d return, “god willing”. Their contracts were expiring anyway, why keep players who have 50 more games under contract when you can get something in return.
And why should the Yankees get on their knees for Arod. He’s getting their money, he doesn’t deserve a ticker tape parade or anything close to the core 4 got.
8 years ago at 3:21 pmSpot on.
8 years ago at 4:42 pmThe 4.5 games out of the wild card would’ve meant something if they weren’t a seller that traded away their three best players. Not to mention you’d be a maniac to think they’d surpass any of Baltimore/Boston/Toronto. Given what ARods contributed to that team in the past he definitely deserved to get to 700 HR, and at the very least deserved to play third base in his last game in New York.
8 years ago at 6:18 pmDo I think they’ll surpass any of those teams, nah. But I can imagine them finishing 5 or so games above .500, which will continue their streak of above .500 seasons. Is it ideal? Nah. But I’ll take a season of “selling” when it entails outplaying the mets, who were “buyers”. At the same time, I get to watch Sanchez, Judge and Austin rip the cover off the ball. My ass will fill a seat the next 2+ months.
8 years ago at 9:50 pmWarren was traded back to the Yankees in the Chapman trade so it wasn’t “free” to get Castro. In retrospect you gave up a lot more for Castro than anticipated due to poor front office decisions
8 years ago at 1:03 pmThat doesn’t even make sense. The Castro trade was Warren and Ryan for Castro. They got Warren back. So in the end, they lost Ryan, and gained Castro. Ryan has negative worth, so they got Castro for less than nothing.
In retrospect, the Yankees gave up a lot less for Castro than anticipated due to great front office decisions.*
8 years ago at 1:00 pmCouldn’t have said it better myself
8 years ago at 12:46 amDon’t get me wrong, the whole team is shit right now. Highest batting average in the past few weeks was sub-.280 but what the did to ARod was shit. When Arod wanted to play 3rd for his last game they say “we don’t owe him anything.” bullshit. Also they cut him 4 short of 700 because they would have owed him 6 mill as a bonus. They just did it to save money and that’s it. Hate on ARod all you want but as a teammate and player, he’s great. Everyone he plays with says he’s a great guy in the clubhouse. He was just used as a scape goat during the PED witch hunt
8 years ago at 3:44 pmYankees are gonna be a subpar team for a year or two, they’re in the rebuilding phase. Getting rid of busts and starting fresh
8 years ago at 3:45 pmThis is straight up a lie btw, he’d get 6 mil for passing Ruth @ 715 and that wasn’t happening any time soon. Don’t make shit up asshat
8 years ago at 5:50 amChapman played 30 games for the Yankees because he was suspended you stupid fuck. The Yankees took a huge risk in trading for him for essentially trash and then held onto him til the deadline to turn him into a top 25 prospect in baseball. It’s called a flip. Also, Arod had 0 value in the Yankees. He couldn’t play in the field, couldn’t pinch run, and this year he couldn’t hit. Even the Yankees worst hitters are plus defenders & runners.
The bottom line is: though the Yankees are “rebuilding” they have the luxury of rebuilding differently than other teams. They have an outside chance of making the playoffs this year and want to assess their young players in the rest of the season to know what to address in the coming off season. It’s not like they’re the fucking Reds and just have to tank for 3 years to hope to have a fieldable team to make a wildcard spot.
8 years ago at 4:35 pmHow can u be siblings of mark wahlberg but not be a Boston fan
8 years ago at 5:18 pmBrian Cashman is a genius. He turned the Yankees farm system from one if the worst to the best in just a few years by adding Judge, Sanchez, and Frazier. He got Chapman on a cheap one year deal because of the domestic violence. He managed to get Castro, a young player and upgrade from Stephen Drew, in a trade. He drafted Betances and Gardner. Not to mention his outstanding trades and free agent signings in 2013, the year the Yanks were supposed to be sub .500. The Yankees are okay without Miller and Chapman because they still have three time all star Betances.
Arod shouldn’t have played in the divisional series against the Sox because the Yankees aren’t that far from a playoff spot. Plus the fans at Fenway would have a field day with Alex. Plus the Yankees needed to give at bats to newly called up Gary Sanchez at DH. Gary Sanchez has gone 10 for 36 since being called up. Arod had a great curtain call at the stadium for a player who was being released.
8 years ago at 6:13 pmPretty shit article as a whole, also Stanton can’t opt out until 2020.
8 years ago at 9:09 pm