Boston College Golfer Can’t Accept Prize Money For Hole-In-One Because NCAA Hates Nice Things

Screen Shot 2015-05-19 at 4.56.20 PM

Brian Butler’s amazing hole-in-one on the 158-yard, par-3 18th hole at the Benrus Open qualifier left him with a tough decision.

Final year of college golf or $10,000?

Unfortunately for Butler, there was no way around it. If he were to accept the prize money for his ace, the NCAA would revoke his amateur status and kick him to the streets. Had he hit the same shot during the actual tournament, he would have pocketed $1,000,000.

From Golfweek:

Butler, who recently completed his junior year at Boston College, where he’s a member of the golf team, turned down a $10,000 prize May 18 after making a hole-in-one in a qualifier for a unique tournament called The Benrus Open at the Preserve.

After talking briefly with his father, Butler, who lives in West Hartford, Conn., had no problem turning down the prize. He’s got one more year of college, and this finance major was able to calculate swiftly that one more year of college golf was worth a lot more than $10,000.

We’ve actually seen stories exactly like this in years past. In 2006, Iowa quarterback Drew Tate nailed a hole-in-one at a charity golf tournament to win $25,000. His athletic director told him he couldn’t accept that money. Luckily, Tate made that money back as a Pro-Bowl NFL quarterba– what’s that? He never made an NFL team’s 53 man-roster? He’s currently the backup quarterback for the Calgary Stampeders? Bet he wishes he had that $25k right about now.

Yeah, $10,000 isn’t a lot of money in the long run. It’s probably just a portion of his future annual income as a finance major (maybe the decision would be different if his diploma read, say, political science), but can we all agree rules that prohibit college athletes from collecting prize money for sinking amazing golf shots is stupid as fuck?

At least let him come back and collect the money in May of next year.

[via Golfweek]

Image via YouTube

  1. SGokies

    Political Science major? Sure you don’t mean art major? Last time I checked the majority of lawyers were political science majors.

    10 years ago at 5:22 pm
      1. PursuitofFrattiness9

        Hey lover of magic why don’t you conjure us up something worth reading.

        10 years ago at 6:05 pm
      2. SGokies

        Before they went to law school they had to get something called a bachelors degree

        10 years ago at 7:03 pm
      3. inhocFaF

        I see what you’re saying, but undergrad law classes full under the umbrella of the Political Science program at my university, so there is certainly some correlation.

        10 years ago at 11:26 am
      4. peaches_n_skeet

        As a current political science major, im going to law school to ensure I dont make shit in life. His statement is valid.

        10 years ago at 9:05 pm
      5. inhocFaF

        My friend graduated with a very ordinary GPA with a Poly Sci degree and he’s a director at a hedge fund. To say you need a finance degree to understand the business world is a stretch.

        10 years ago at 11:01 pm
      6. SperryHairy

        Yeah, they have graduate law degrees. But most aspiring lawyers, at least at my school, major in something like political science, government, or public policy for undergrad.

        10 years ago at 2:00 pm
  2. AEKDBallin

    Can he get the check and just hold onto it for a year? Cash it the day of graduation and throw a rager. No harm, no foul.

    10 years ago at 7:03 pm
  3. beerbong_in_my_pants

    Couldn’t he just wait a year and collect it? I’m sure those guys couldn’t be so heartless as to not help a kid out. I mean it’s not like they are the NCAA.

    10 years ago at 8:13 pm
  4. RedPill

    Helmet Stickers one had a hole in one at his public muni course.
    The prize was two minor league baseball tickets and a free cart rental.

    10 years ago at 8:13 pm
  5. FratDrunkandStupid

    As soon as he accepts money, he loses amateur status. As much as the NCAA sucks, this one isn’t really on them.

    10 years ago at 8:39 pm
    1. FratMuscle

      Unfamiliar with the rules, does someone not in college accepting a hole-in-one prize give them pro status?

      10 years ago at 9:21 pm
  6. Beecher1843

    The NCAA doesn’t hate nice things, it just hates nice tings for the athletes it wouldn’t be able to exist without.

    10 years ago at 12:17 pm
  7. SperryHairy

    Your major doesn’t matter half as much as your school’s reputation, your GPA, and how good you are at networking.

    10 years ago at 2:06 pm